Configure Enhanced Open SSID with Transition Mode - OWE

Introduction

This document describes how to configure and troubleshoot Enhanced Open with Transition Mode on Catalyst 9800 Wireless LAN Controller (9800 WLC).

Prerequisites

Requirements

Cisco recommends that you have knowledge of these topics:

• Cisco Wireless Lan Controllers (WLC) 9800.
• Cisco Access Points (APs) that support Wi-Fi 6E. 
• IEEE Standard 802.11ax.
• Wireshark.

Components Used

The information in this document is based on these software and hardware versions:

• WLC 9800-CL with IOS® XE 17.9.3.
• APs C9130, C9136, CW9162, CW9164 and CW9166.
• Wi-Fi 6 Clients: 
  • iPhone SE3rd gen on IOS 16
  • MacBook on Mac OS 12.
• Wi-Fi 6E Clients:
  • Lenovo X1 Carbon Gen11 with Intel AX211 Wi-Fi 6 and 6E Adapter with driver version 22.200.2(1).
  • Netgear A8000 Wi-Fi 6 and 6E Adapter with driver v1(0.0.108);
  • Mobile Phone Pixel 6a with Android 13;
  • Mobile Phone Samsung S23 with Android 13.

The information in this document was created from the devices in a specific lab environment. All of the devices used in this document started with a cleared (default) configuration. If your network is live, ensure that you understand the potential impact of any command.

Background Information

The Enhanced Open is a certification provided by WiFi alliance as part of the WPA3 wireless security standard. It uses Opportunistic Wireless Encryption (OWE) on Open (unauthenticated) networks to prevent passive sniffing and prevent simple attacks as compared to a public PSK wireless network. 

With Enhanced Open, clients and the WLC (in case of Central Authentication) or the AP (in case of FlexConnect Local Authentication) perform a Diffie-Hellman key exchange during the association process and use the pairwise master key secret (PMK) with the 4-way handshake. 

OWE

Opportunistic Wireless Encryption (OWE) is an extension to IEEE 802.11 that provides encryption of the wireless medium (IETF RFC 8110). The purpose of OWE based authentication is avoid open unsecured wireless connectivity between the AP’s and clients. The OWE uses the Diffie-Hellman algorithms based Cryptography to setup the wireless encryption. With OWE, the client and AP perform a Diffie-Hellman key exchange during the access procedure and use the resulting pairwise master key (PMK) secret with the 4-way handshake. The use of OWE enhances wireless network security for deployments where Open or shared PSK based networks are deployed.

OWE frame exchange

Transition Mode

Typically enterprise networks only have one unencrypted guest SSID and prefer to have both older clients that do not support enhanced open and newer clients with enhanced open to co-exist. Transition Mode is introduced specifically to cater to this scenario.

This requires configuration of two SSIDs - one hidden SSID to support OWE and a second SSID that is Open and is broadcasted.

The Opportunistic Wireless Encryption (OWE) transition mode enables OWE and non-OWE STAs to connect to the same SSID simultaneously. When all the OWE STAs see an SSID in OWE transition mode, they connect with the OWE.

Both the open WLAN and the OWE WLAN transmit beacon frames. Beacon and probe response frames from the OWE WLAN include the Wi-Fi Alliance vendor IE to encapsulate the BSSID and SSID of the open WLAN, and similarly, the open WLAN also includes for OWE WLAN.

An OWE STA shall only display to the user in the list of available networks the SSID of the Open BSS of an OWE AP operating in OWE Transition Mode, and shall suppress the display of the OWE BSS SSID of that OWE AP.

Guidelines and Restrictions:

• Enhanced open requires WPA3 only Policy. WPA3 is not supported in Cisco Wave 1 (Cisco IOS®-based) APs.
• Protected Management Frame (PMF) must be set to Required. This is set by default with WPA3 only Layer 2 Security.
• Enhanced Open only works on end clients that run the newer versions that support Enhanced Open.

Configure

Typical use case where the administrator wants to configure Enhanced Open but still allow for older clients to be able to connect to the guest SSID.

Network Diagram

Network Topology

Configuration steps for GUI:

Create first SSID, hereby called “OWE_Transition”. In this example WLAN ID 3, and ensure it is hidden with the option “Broadcast SSID” disabled:

Step 1         Choose Configuration > Tags & Profiles > WLANs to open the WLANs page.

Step 2         Click Add to add new WLAN > add WLAN name "OWE_Transition"  > change Status to Enable > ensure Broadcast SSID is Disabled.

OWE Transition Enhanced Open SSID hidden

Step 3         Choose the Security > Layer 2 tab > Select WPA3.

Step 4         Set Protected Management Frame (PMF) to Required.

Step 5         Under WPA Parameters > Check the WPA3 Policy. Select AES(CCMP128) Encryption and OWE Auth Key Management.

Step 6         Add WLAN ID 4 (open WLAN) to "Transition Mode WLAN ID" box.

Step 7         Click Apply to Device.

OWE Transition Mode - OWE SSID

Create second SSID, call it “open” in this example WLAN ID 4, and ensure you enable “Broadcast SSID”:

Step 1         Choose Configuration > Tags & Profiles > WLANs to open the WLANs page.

Step 2         Click Add to add new WLAN > add WLAN name "open"  > change Status to Enable > ensure Broadcast SSID is Enabled.

OWE Transition Open SSID

Step 3         Choose the Security > Layer 2 tab > Choose None.

Step 4         Add WLAN ID 4 (OWE_Transition) to "Transition Mode WLAN ID" box.

Step 5         Click Apply to Device.

OWE Transition Mode Open WLAN Security

Caution: In case you had a previous open WLAN using the same SSID of the OWE WLAN, Windows clients will append “2” to the SSID name. To overcome this, navigate to “Network & Internet > Wi-Fi > Manage known networks” and delete the old connection.

This screenshot shows the final result: one WLAN is secured and configured for WPA3+OWE+WPA3 named "OWE_Transition" and the other is a fully open SSID named "open". Only the fully open SSID called “open” has its SSID broadcasted in the beacons while "OWE_Transition" is hidden.

OWE Transition Mode WLANs

Step 6         Map the WLANs created to the desired Policy Profiles into the Policy Tag and apply it to the APs.

Policy Tag

Configure for CLI:

Enhanced Open SSID:

Device# conf t
Device(config)# wlan OWE_Transition 3 OWE_Transition
Device(config)# no broadcast-ssid
Device(config)# no security ft adaptive
Device(config)# no security wpa wpa2
Device(config)# no security wpa akm dot1x
Device(config)# security wpa akm owe
Device(config)# security wpa transition-mode-wlan-id 4
Device(config)# security wpa wpa3
Device(config)# security pmf mandatory
Device(config)# no shutdown

Open SSID:

Device# conf t
Device(config)# wlan open 4 open
Device(config)# no security ft adaptive
Device(config)# no security wpa
Device(config)# no security wpa wpa2
Device(config)# no security wpa wpa2 ciphers aes
Device(config)# no security wpa akm dot1x
Device(config)# security wpa transition-mode-wlan-id 3
Device(config)# no shutdown

Policy Profile:

Device(config)# wireless tag policy Wifi6E_TestPolicy
Device(config-policy-tag)# wlan open policy CentralSwPolicyProfile
Device(config-policy-tag)# wlan OWE_Transition policy CentralSwPolicyProfile

Verify

This is the verification section.

Verify the WLANs configuration on CLI:

Device#show wlan id 3
WLAN Profile Name : OWE_Transition
================================================
Identifier : 3
Description : 
Network Name (SSID) : OWE_Transition
Status : Enabled
Broadcast SSID : Disabled
[...]
Security
802.11 Authentication : Open System
Static WEP Keys : Disabled
Wi-Fi Protected Access (WPA/WPA2/WPA3) : Enabled
WPA (SSN IE) : Disabled
WPA2 (RSN IE) : Disabled
WPA3 (WPA3 IE) : Enabled
AES Cipher : Enabled
CCMP256 Cipher : Disabled
GCMP128 Cipher : Disabled
GCMP256 Cipher : Disabled
Auth Key Management
802.1x : Disabled
PSK : Disabled
CCKM : Disabled
FT dot1x : Disabled
FT PSK : Disabled
FT SAE : Disabled
Dot1x-SHA256 : Disabled
PSK-SHA256 : Disabled
SAE : Disabled
OWE : Enabled
SUITEB-1X : Disabled
SUITEB192-1X : Disabled
SAE PWE Method : Hash to Element, Hunting and Pecking(H2E-HNP)
Transition Disable : Disabled
CCKM TSF Tolerance (msecs) : 1000
OWE Transition Mode : Enabled
OWE Transition Mode WLAN ID : 4
OSEN : Disabled
FT Support : Disabled
FT Reassociation Timeout (secs) : 20
FT Over-The-DS mode : Disabled
PMF Support : Required
PMF Association Comeback Timeout (secs): 1
PMF SA Query Time (msecs) : 200
[...]
#show wlan id 4
WLAN Profile Name : open
================================================
Identifier : 4
Description : 
Network Name (SSID) : open
Status : Enabled
Broadcast SSID : Enabled
[...]
Security
802.11 Authentication : Open System
Static WEP Keys : Disabled
Wi-Fi Protected Access (WPA/WPA2/WPA3) : Disabled
OWE Transition Mode : Enabled
OWE Transition Mode WLAN ID : 3
OSEN : Disabled
FT Support : Disabled
FT Reassociation Timeout (secs) : 20
FT Over-The-DS mode : Disabled
PMF Support : Disabled
PMF Association Comeback Timeout (secs): 1
PMF SA Query Time (msecs) : 200
[...]

In the WLC you can go to the AP Configuration and verify that both WLANs are active on the AP:

OWE Transition Mode AP Operational Configuration Viewer

When enabled, the AP only beacons with Open SSID but carry an OWE Transition Mode Information Element (IE). When a client capable of enhanced open connects to this SSID, it automatically uses OWE to encrypt all traffic post association.

Here is what you can observe over the air (OTA):

OWE Transition Open SSID Beacon

The beacon send with SSID "open" contains the OWE Transition Mode IE with the enhanced open SSID details inside, like BSSID and SSID name "OWE_Transition".

There are also beacons OTA with the SSID hidden and if we filter by bssid, the frames are sent to the BSSID 00:df:1d:dd:7d:3e which is the BSSID inside the OWE Transition Mode IE:

OWE Beacon

You can see that also the OWE hidden beacon contains the OWE Transition Mode IE with the open ssid BSSID and SSID name "open".

These screenshots show an Android phone that supports Enhanced Open: it only displays the open SSID with no lock icon (a lock icon would make the user believe it requires a password to connect), but once connected the security shows Enhanced Open security is used.

OWE SSID listOWE Client with Enhanced Open support

Over the air, we can see the full connection sequence:

OWE Transition full connection

After listening to the beacons, the client probes for the OWE SSID and the AP responds.

Then occurs the normal OWE frame exchange: authentication request and response, association request and reponse containing the DH IE, and then the EAPOL 4-way handshake. 

On the WLC you can verify the client connection. Client that supports OWE can connect to Enhanced Open WLAN in this example it is WLAN ID 3:

Device#show wireless client mac-address 286b.3598.580f detail

Client MAC Address : 286b.3598.580f
[...]
AP Name: AP9136_5C.F524
AP slot : 1
Client State : Associated
Policy Profile : CentralSwPolicyProfile
Flex Profile : N/A
Wireless LAN Id: 3
WLAN Profile Name: OWE_Transition
Wireless LAN Network Name (SSID): OWE_Transition
BSSID : 00df.1ddd.7d3e
Connected For : 682 seconds 
Protocol : 802.11ax - 5 GHz
Channel : 64
Client IIF-ID : 0xa0000003
Association Id : 2
Authentication Algorithm : Open System
Idle state timeout : N/A
[...]
Policy Type : WPA3
Encryption Cipher : CCMP (AES)
Authentication Key Management : OWE
Transition Disable Bitmap : None
User Defined (Private) Network : Disabled
User Defined (Private) Network Drop Unicast : Disabled
Encrypted Traffic Analytics : No
Protected Management Frame - 802.11w : Yes
EAP Type : Not Applicable

And we can observe the same in the WLC GUI:

For clients that do not support Enhanced Open, they only see and connect to the open SSID, with no encryption.

As illustrated here, these are clients that do not support Enhanced Open (respectively an iPhone on IOS 15 and a MacBook on Mac OS 12) and only see the open guest SSID and do not use encryption.

Device that does not support OWEFigure 4 : MacBook on Mac OS 12 not supporting Enhanced Open

Here another example of a USB wireless adapter that does not support OWE:

Client that does not support Enhanced Open

Client does not support OWE can connect to Open WLAN in this example it is WLAN ID 4:

#show wireless client mac-address b44b.d623.a199 detail

Client MAC Address : b44b.d623.a199
[...]
AP Name: AP9136_5C.F524
AP slot : 1
Client State : Associated
Policy Profile : CentralSwPolicyProfile
Flex Profile : N/A
Wireless LAN Id: 4
WLAN Profile Name: open
Wireless LAN Network Name (SSID): open
BSSID : 00df.1ddd.7d3f
[...]
Authentication Algorithm : Open System
[...]
Protected Management Frame - 802.11w : No
EAP Type : Not Applicable

Troubleshoot

1. Ensure that client supports OWE, as not all clients support it. Check the client vendor documentation, for example Apple documented the support for their devices here.
   
2. Some older clients possibly do not even accept the Open ssid beacons due to the presence of the OWE Transition Mode IE and not present the SSID in the networks in range. If your client cannot see the Open SSID, remove the Transition VLAN (set to 0) from the WLAN configuration and check if it sees the WLAN then.
3. If clients see open SSID, support OWE, but they still connect without WPA3, then verify if the transition VLAN id is correct and being broadcasted in the beacons of both WLANs. You can use AP in sniffer mode to capture OTA traffic. Please execute these steps to configure an AP in sniffer mode: APs Catalyst 91xx in Sniffer Mode .
   • The beacon is sent with SSID "open" contains the OWE Transition Mode IE with the enhanced open SSID details inside, like BSSID and SSID name "OWE_Transition":OWE Transition Open SSID Beacon

   • There are also beacons OTA with the SSID hidden and if we filter by bssid, the frames are sent to the BSSID 00:df:1d:dd:7d:3e which is the BSSID inside the OWE Transition Mode IE:

     OWE Beacon

     You can see that also the OWE hidden beacon contains the OWE Transition Mode IE with the open ssid BSSID and SSID name "open".

   • You can as well see AKM info and verify that MFP is advertised as Required and Capable:
   • OWE Beacon AKM
4. Collect RadioActive traces based on client mac address and you see similar logs as this:

2023/06/23 15:08:58.567933 {wncd_x_R0-0}{1}: [client-keymgmt] [14854]: (note): MAC: xxxx.xxxx.xxxx EAP Key management successful. AKM:OWE Cipher:CCMP WPA Version: WPA3

2023/06/23 15:10:06.971651 {wncd_x_R0-0}{1}: [client-orch-state] [14854]: (note): MAC: xxxx.xxxx.xxxx Client state transition: S_CO_IP_LEARN_IN_PROGRESS -> S_CO_RUN

References

What is Wi-Fi 6E?

What Is Wi-Fi 6 vs. Wi-Fi 6E?

Wi-Fi 6E At-a-Glance

Wi-Fi 6E: The Next Great Chapter in Wi-Fi White Paper

Cisco Catalyst 9800 Series Wireless Controller Software Configuration Guide 17.9.x

WPA3 Deployment Guide